Today we review a merlot from Napa Valley, California that costs $40 a bottle.
OK this is a ridiculous review, because I am going to “not recommend” a very, very good wine. The problem is the price. The wine is the 2006 Stags’ Leap merlot. Big, oaky, with kickass tannins YET bursting with juicy dark fruit flavors all over the place, and silky smooth. And organic. Once you let it breathe, this wine smells and tastes very natural, very much “off the farm,” with all kinds of interesting notes calling for your attention. Stags’ Leap is definitely not your typical processed, corporate, red juice. Which is what you’d expect, because the Stags’ Leap area of Napa Valley is some of the most high-fallootin’ grape farmland in the entire world.
As with any very good wine, drinking this merlot is like having an artist’s palette explode in your mouth. You suddenly realize why all the $10 wines that you have been drinking were priced that way – because (compared to the really good stuff) they are bleached out of real flavor and are overly simplistic or ”one flavor only.”
But here’s the thing — at $40, I expect something seriously compelling. The Stags’ Leap is truly lovely, but it’s really just a great merlot. If it were $25, it would merit a huge recommendation. So there you have it. A very, very good wine, which is: